ReactJS vs Backbone: Which is better for your next web project

black flat screen computer monitor - Javascript program in a vscode code editor with Dracula theme, tags: web - unsplash

When starting a new web project, selecting a development framework is a priority. The most fitting framework will aid developers in constructing websites, web apps, web services, web APIs and web resources, as well as streamline the development process.

The choice of web framework relies on the project’s specific requirements and the development team’s preferences. However, among many, Backbone.js and ReactJS, despite both being libraries and not fully-pledged frameworks, are commonly used in numerous web projects.

While both stand as popular web development frameworks, distinctions exist between them. React surpasses Backbone in usage and boasts a more vibrant community with its robust support for the framework. Functioning primarily as a view layer framework, React optimizes UI updates, enhancing the speed of web applications by offering precisely the necessary tools and features for streamlined tasks.

In contrast, Backbone adopts the Model View (MV) framework, providing a structured approach to JavaScript development. It proves to be an excellent choice for both front-end and back-end development, leveraging support for REST APIs to maintain a clear separation between the front-end and back-end components.

Given the multitude of impressive options, selecting the optimal front-end framework in the JavaScript ecosystem presents a challenge. Sorting through recommendations and suggestions demands effort and patience before arriving at a final decision.

Backbone vs. React overview

As an MVC architecture-based JavaScript framework, Backbone is ideal for efficiently developing single-page applications (SPAs). It utilizes engines like Mustache and Underscore.js, ensuring quick operations.

With seamless model separation through numerous collections, Backbone excels in handling applications with multiple users. It also extends its prowess to back-end development, supporting REST APIs for synchronized front-end and back-end interactions.

In the Backbone ecosystem, you can discover various libraries encompassing events, models, collections, views and a router. The command-line interface facilitates trunk application generation, while the BackPlug repository offers ready-to-use solutions for Backbone applications.

Meanwhile, React is known for creating dynamic web applications. This library boasts extensions like Flux and React Native for comprehensive architectural support. Flux facilitates seamless component communication, while React introduces unique objects – states and properties – for efficient data transfer between components.

The React ecosystem features the React Create App for a user-friendly command-line interface and React Native for developing native mobile apps on iOS and Android. React DOM and DOM manipulation further enhance its capabilities.

Coding compatibility, performance and more

Backbone has a clear, readable codebase when it comes to coding compatibility. However, while it has a straightforward foundation, using Backbone may require learning additional frameworks as projects advance.

On the other hand, React’s simple component model ensures precise and fast code leveling. It is also considered more beginner-friendly due to the extensive online guidance and tutorials.

From the popularity based on GitHub stars and forks, website numbers and site rankings, React also emerges on top with a larger community. This community also helps React with documentation support as it regularly dishes out updates and maintenance, unlike Backbone, whose updates and support are less consistent.

When it comes to performance, React’s cross-platform compatibility and virtual DOM deliver efficient UI updates. Meanwhile, Backbone’s complexity may impede performance, especially with two-way data binding.

Backbone, lightweight and extensible, excels in server-side synchronization but lacks two-way data binding. React, which is backward compatible and features reusable components, simplifies testing but may face integration challenges.

With each library’s pros and cons, it is key to carefully choose optimal use cases for each. Backbone.js shines in avoiding spaghetti code, simplifying complex UIs and reducing server requests. React excels in developing cross-platform apps, eCommerce or retail websites and enterprise web applications.